Although I played sports growing up, I had a number of friends in the musical theater program. And I was always a big fan of seeing their shows (and going to shows on Broadway, too!). So I’ve compiled a list of Broadway gifts for the beloved musical theater geeks in your life. While you may not be buying them tickets to a show, what’s better than a copy of the “Oh, Mary!” stageplay, a “Mamma Mia” crew neck or a high-end Elphaba-inspired candle?
Peruse some of my top picks for Broadway-themed gifts. And if you have a few too many glasses of wine at your Christmas gathering and end up putting on a show, I’ll be cheering you on from right here.
Top Broadway Gifts For Musical Theater Geeks
- Day to Day: Don’t throw away their shot! Help your giftee keep track of the date with a 2026 “Hamilton”-themed calendar. The Tony award-winning show is sure to get them ready to seize the day. Regardless, history has its eyes on you! — $18
- All That Jazz: With the latest “Secret Lives of Mormon Wives” addition to the “Chicago” cast, the Broadway geek in your life is likely craving a re-listen of the original cast’s soundtrack. So why not get it on vinyl? That way, they can listen to the OGs again and again — $27
- Nostalgia: Keep all of their beloved Broadway memorabilia in one place! This Broadway Playbill binder keeps their Playbills together in one organized book. And the plastic protective sheets ensure they’ll last forever — $37
- Defying Gravity: With the recent release of “Wicked: For Good,” relevant merch isn’t hard to find right now. For example, luxe candle company Voluspa is capitalizing with some seriously enchanting candles. Get Perfectly Pink Yuzu for the Glinda in your life, and Bewitching Banyan Forest for Elphaba. Either way, they’ll be changed for good — both $48
- I Believe: Ensure your favorite piano player’s holiday isn’t a spooky Mormon hell dream. Instead, get them all the Book of Mormon sheet music. That way, they can make holiday gatherings even better, with a jolly rendition of “Hasa Diga Eebowai” — $30
- I’m a Queen: Cole Escola’s “Oh, Mary!” has taken the theater world by storm! Although it isn’t a musical, there’s a very likely chance the Broadway aficionado in your life is dying to read the witty stage play—and fortunately—copies of the stageplay are now available — $45
- Bucket List: They can keep track of what they’ve seen, and what they plan to see, with a scratch-off Broadway poster. Take note, though, the poster does not include a frame — $22
- Dancing Queen: Gimme, gimme, gimme this “Mamma Mia” Broadway Musical Crew Neck! It comes in a wide range of colors and sizes, and quite frankly, I love all of them — $41
- Don’t Lose Your Head: Rep the beloved wives of King Henry VIII with a “Six the Musical” bumper sticker. Since it’s waterproof, it should last forever — $5
- Master of the House: I dreamed a dream that I owned a “Les Mis” leather-bound collectible book. While I can’t imagine your giftee will re-read this long-winded classic over and over, it’s a unique and fancy addition to their bookshelf — $43
Back
Free Unlimited Delivery When You Start Your Free Trial.
